Logo Background RSS


Large Speculator Positions: Deadly Divergences Grow

  • Written by Syndicated Publisher No Comments Comments
    October 31, 2011

    As previously stated the Commitment Of Trader’s Report is a wealth of information as it discloses long and short positions across the entire futures and commodity complex. I want to share with you some aggregated data on one specific group, non-commercial which represents hedge funds, banks, anyone considered a large speculator.

    The basis for the three charts below is that large speculators will have a position on either short or long and use a hedge to manage risk and adjust the overall position. This is no different than a retail trader who may hold SPY puts and hedge by selling and buying puts against the underlying position.

    Chart 1 – Position VS SPX

    The “position” shown below is the net position for multiple asset classes combined into one. Throughout the year it has correlated very well with the SPX.  Notice how during August, September and even October this position has increased in overall net short.


    Chart 2 – Hedge VS Postion

    Similar to the “position” the hedge consists of net positions across various asset classes combined into one “hedge.” Notice how non-commercial began reducing their hedge in August to expand their overall net short position.

    This would be similar to a retail trader who feels the downside risk has increased and reduces their short put hedge for they want to capture more downside. It is not until the Dexia ramp that they begin to aggressively add back their hedge to reduce overall exposure.

    Chart 3 – Position Delta

    Delta means how directional a trade is. If delta is negative the trade is positioned for lower prices and if positive higher prices. The more negative delta the more the position profits in falling prices and vice versa. By combining charts 1 and 2 above you can get an overall position delta for non-commercial traders.

    Bottom line

    Right or wrong, non-commercial is not buying this rally. They have actually increased their net short position and simply increased their hedge over the past few weeks to manage short term upside risk. If they were truly behind this move you would expect a sharp reduction not expansion in their overall position.

    Images: Flickr (licence attribution)

    About the Author

    Macro Story is designed as a one stop source for all of your macro related news and data.  From credit markets to economic data to geopolitics, you will find it all in a simple and organized fashion.  Content is presented in a format that allows you to read as little or as much as prefered.  Whether your goal is to do advanced research, a simple market overview or to become educated on macro subjects, the site has been designed with you in mind.


Closed Comments are currently closed.